|
Post by scott on Aug 4, 2009 13:59:22 GMT
Does anybody know if, for the top shot stopper award goals are being deducted from saves to decide who won?
Im sure its been mentioned last season as other wise the best performing keeper doesnt win the award
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 4, 2009 17:41:21 GMT
it has and always was: the most saves.
even though it should be best performing keeper!
|
|
|
Post by scott on Aug 4, 2009 18:01:18 GMT
Think this needs changing then, not just cos its my gk, seems a bit odd that, in essense,the gk with the weakest team infront of him gets a bonus
|
|
|
Post by garfy on Aug 4, 2009 18:06:49 GMT
But if he wasnt a SUPER KEEPER then he would not make the saves just let them all in!!! So he must have a bit of talent to get in the way sometimes....
|
|
|
Post by scott on Aug 4, 2009 19:14:12 GMT
but he has let the most goals in out of every team
|
|
|
Post by tone on Aug 4, 2009 20:59:44 GMT
but he has let the most goals in out of every team then he would have conceeded more if he wasnt a super keeper
|
|
|
Post by scott on Aug 5, 2009 8:05:05 GMT
what do you class as more?
Lets be honest, there is no defining amount of goals a player must concede to be classed "rubbish"
facts are, it should work off conceded to shots saved, otherwise this happens.
He has saved nine extra shots than my keeper, yet conceded 19 more goals, surely you lot can see the fault in the system with those figures?
|
|
|
Post by garfy on Aug 5, 2009 8:33:26 GMT
Actually EOS awards based on the top performers harm the games development.
The best players - who already gain the most abs in the season - gain even more abs at the EOS and gallop away from the pack to become super ab stealers the season after and become even more likely to gain the EOS abs the season after.
Too late for this season but perhaps a small change?
The top players win the award - but if they are the best skilled player in that position in your squad they cannot actually be given the award.
Confused ? - Let me give you an example
Inter Milans midfield:
Xavi 23 spa 1 4 29 2 20 300 757 118 979 24 F_Lampard 28 eng 1 2 26 2 32 300 703 575 690 M_Essien 23 gha 1 2 26 5 39 300 408 271 933 M_Valbuena 20 fra 2 11 22 9 45 500 62 171 859 C_RodrÃguez 31 uru 1 8 21 8 28 800 263 640 164 A_Schreuder 23 arg 2 9 18 4 38 300 32 103 790
and say Xavi wins the league passing award - 200 abs - then you cannot give Xavi the award but give it to another MF player instead - therefore spreading the player abs about whilst rewarding the team still.
ALthough if Lampard wins the award then he can keep it.
Doesnt solve the "Best Keeper" award - but does balance the fact that a good keeper behind a rubbish defence will win save abs throughout the season and then the main award at the end!
|
|