|
Post by scott777 on Mar 1, 2015 20:52:04 GMT
Chris your deal wasn't good for him in any way. He got a worse player and a yth who will never be a first teamer.
As a one off deal though, it isn't an issue. The issue is he has made loads and not one makes sense.
|
|
|
Post by johnraggett on Mar 1, 2015 21:13:55 GMT
Bergkamp was up for.auction and he won it what's wrong with that? ? Bergkamp, ain't worth half that. And as Scott said a defender of similar ability sold for 3 mil. A midfielder 3 still higher sold for less. NoTt one deal is of the good for Lyon
|
|
|
Post by johnraggett on Mar 1, 2015 21:16:22 GMT
I was surprised Scott left it out of the deals that make no sense. Just look at historic deals to see what a 24 rated 34 year old striker is worth and you'll struggle to see one going for 5mil
|
|
|
Post by garfy on Mar 3, 2015 21:18:44 GMT
Pretty sure I have said it before but in a game I played 10 years ago the Admin had a rough guide for pricing. It was along the lines of:
SKILL VALUE GK DF MF FW
10 1 2 3 4 11 2 4 5 6
AGE VALUE GK DF MF FW
10 1. 2. 3. 4 11 2 3. 3. 3
Kinda thing (done on iPad so probably out of line lol)
Based on the scout value and tweaked by the mods to correct for market trends. This would allow for a newer manager to see that on average a skill 11 aged 11 MF would be approx 8m And allow for a better comparison for a deal.
Obviously needs etc will always determine prices but a rough guide for newbies would remove any honest errors. I am happy to build a provisional model if people think it may help?
|
|
|
Post by pom on Mar 4, 2015 17:34:21 GMT
I honestly don't want to get in a huge fight, because I feel like this is where it is going. I just want to say "No comment" right now but I guess I should explain everything.. Before I say anything else I just want to say I don't mean to offend anyone right now. This is just really frustrating me and this isn't making my experience quite enjoyable right now. I'm new to all this. I can't help it. I don't exactly know how to value players based on their stats and all that, alright? This is all (well, not completely) new to me, I mean I know what I am doing, I know the rules of football and all that, but I have never played an online football manager game like this before. I saw Ahmed's deal, I misread some stats, and I thought it would be a good deal. After looking at it again, I noticed I made a mistake. Ahmed and I had a peaceful talk and we both came to the conclusion that the transfer was a little unfair, so we got all the players we transferred back and everything is back to normal. I realize I am no where near being the best manager in this game, and I realize my team is a bunch of old people. I'm working on bringing young people to the team. I just don't see why we all need to get in a big debate because of this transfer. Ahmed and I never meant to make anyone mad or anything about this. I apologize for any inconvenience I have caused or whatever. I'm still figuring things out. Arag - None of this is directed at you at all - we seem to go through this every time a new manager comes in Seen as you admit you've never played an online game - Why the rush to change your team ... I wouldn't even worry about the ageing players atm - just replace them gradually ... If it was upto me I'd cancel all the transfers .... This is why I've always said a new manager should not be allowed to make transfers within their first 10 games when taking over an established team (especially an Elite team) this gives the manager time to adjust to 'our game' ( why completely change a 'winning team' within a couple of weeks) Should be a condition on joining .... (like it or don't join) Would prefer to see a caretaker than someone just ripping up a team that has been developed over a number of seasons by a good manager .... Can we please bring in a rule regarding transfers to protect new managers ?
|
|