|
Post by gazza on Oct 30, 2015 11:21:25 GMT
Looking for an opinion on this one, not suspicious just a bit one sided in my opinion.
Yes or no guys.
Everton I_Falque 28 spa 3 14 25 9 19 300 318 594 610 J_Rodwell 27 eng 2 5 19 14 43 300 637 912 765
Swap
Newcastle I_Harte 19 ire 2 19 7 6 20 500 538 518 504 J_Serwy 20 bel 2 10 19 10 22 800 86 274 150 +5M
|
|
|
Post by Ahmed@Real on Oct 30, 2015 11:54:12 GMT
It is one sided, very great deal for Newcastle; strange is Tone still managing them or somebody else
|
|
Rune
Youth Player
Posts: 172
|
Post by Rune on Oct 30, 2015 12:34:48 GMT
Just check if Tone has made a c**k up! Seems very one sided!
|
|
|
Post by trulskaare on Oct 31, 2015 11:37:42 GMT
I have to agree. There's only one player worth mentioning in this deal, so the 5mill isn't anywhere near the fee needed to make this a balanced deal.
|
|
|
Post by tone on Nov 3, 2015 7:18:19 GMT
The deal i put through was for a different player. The deal you see was a counter offer from everton. I dont see anything wrong with it. It has now been withdrawn. cheers guys
|
|
|
Post by Ahmed@Real on Nov 3, 2015 8:28:09 GMT
The deal i put through was for a different player. The deal you see was a counter offer from everton. I dont see anything wrong with it. It has now been withdrawn. cheers guys You did nothing wrong and you should kept him, yes it is one sided deal but deal is deal and we are not talking about new manager here, in any case I don’t understand how the players went to Gazza, it is not auction!!! I don’t like it if I make a deal then somebody in the Panel stop the deal then he take it to himself because he make a better offer
|
|
|
Post by gazza on Nov 3, 2015 8:53:03 GMT
The deal i put through was for a different player. The deal you see was a counter offer from everton. I dont see anything wrong with it. It has now been withdrawn. cheers guys You did nothing wrong and you should kept him, yes it is one sided deal but deal is deal and we are not talking about new manager here, in any case I don’t understand how the players went to Gazza, it is not auction!!! I don’t like it if I make a deal then somebody in the Panel stop the deal then he take it to himself because he make a better offer I posted the deal on the site , the deal went on whatsapp and I Pm'd Malky and Garfy, this deal was out there for anyone to counter offer and Garfy stated he had no offers, So I made an offer which was a good one and to be honest I didn't really need the player, but I hate to see one sided deals. The original deal was cancelled I messaged Garfy and he stated his reasons and what he was looking for, I made him an offer that met all his terms, maybe he would like to comment. If you see any wrong doing in the deal Ahmed, then put it in the section queerying transfer deals, and like any other deal it can be investigated and reversed in an amicable way. The fact that deals are being scrutinised is great for the game, it will ensure fairness and stop people taking the p!ss, I am all for that by the way, so I take all negative and positive comments in a constructive way. All opinions regards this deal are more than welcome.
|
|
|
Post by gazza on Nov 3, 2015 8:58:42 GMT
Ahmed it was not an Auction your right, so do we not bid on any players that are not up for Auction ?
Send Garfy a message and I am sure he will let you know the offers on the table after he pulled out the original one sided deal, pretty sure he got himself a good deal, and the fact the deal was flagged enabled this to happen.
Understand now buddy !!!
|
|
|
Post by Ahmed@Real on Nov 3, 2015 10:11:49 GMT
I don’t talking about your deal if it is fair or not and yes it is better than Tone offer, I talking about a principles, Of course Tone is not taking the p!ss, simple because he dont make the offer But that will open another door, and give the Transfer Panel some advantage, so if I make a deal for a player for example £30m you could say it is not fair and you stop the deal and offer £40m if you fancy that player specially everybody now value the players in different way and the cash worth nothing for somebody but mean lots for somebody else. This is my point even Tone dont have the chance to improve his offer (and he dont need to because again it is not auction)
|
|
|
Post by gazza on Nov 3, 2015 11:59:08 GMT
I get your point Ahmed, but Tone and everyone else had the chance to make another offer, people were made aware of the original deal.
Garfy makes the decision to accept, and Malky approves the deal.
I didn't approve the deal as it wasn't a fair one, my deal was fair in my opinion.
If people deem it unfair as I had the heads up on it due to me helping with the approval of deals then maybe that can be seen as insider knowledge.
That's why I notified people of the deal, Garfy had the say on accepting, then it was down to Malky.
Simples
|
|
|
Post by tone on Nov 3, 2015 12:40:46 GMT
The transfer offer between two managers shiuld stay between them and not posted on an outside source especally when it involves one manager that doesnt use that source a bit shit if you ask me
|
|
|
Post by gazza on Nov 3, 2015 14:07:02 GMT
I help with transfers and we have a transfer panel section in the forum, maybe the forum should be locked to most players, we could discuss everything behind all your backs if that's more appropriate.
|
|
|
Post by gazza on Nov 3, 2015 14:09:18 GMT
As for the outside source, I take that on board, but I contacted garfy and malky without reply, I wanted a response by the whole EFL community for transparency reasons, so all game avenues were used.
The deal wouldn't have even been discussed had your offer not been so ridiculous as agreed by most.
|
|
|
Post by tone on Nov 3, 2015 15:35:55 GMT
This wasnt a complete transfer it was still in negotiations. The info on my page should not be accessed by anyone else or whats the point in having passwords
|
|
|
Post by tone on Nov 3, 2015 15:38:02 GMT
As said it wasnt my offer it was his i was after a different player that was his counter offer
|
|