|
Post by trulskaare on Nov 7, 2019 9:02:13 GMT
I thought players aged 17 and under couldn't have their main skill more than three above their age: Due to the changes in the scouting system for season 9 it is now nessasary to put rules/caps/guidelines into place regarding aged 17 and under 17 players scouted This is to stop 'super youths' being produced and wasting the game seasons down the line The Changes are as follows. 1. Youth players aged 13,14 & 15 can't be donated on. 2. Youth players aged 13,14 & 15 will not receive EOS bonuses 3. Youth players aged 17 and under can't have there main skill any more than three higher than there age, if a youth player progress too fast there skill will be frozen until they reach aged 18 Rangers have just donated to push Bovan's skill above this threshold: Bovan 17 isr 3 9 20 11 43 500 500 500 500 to Bovan 17 isr 3 9 21 11 43 500 500 500 500 If this was possible, I would have donated on my youth striker too: P_B_E_Dybala 17 arg 2 6 8 20 22 500 500 500 500 I think these rules need to be clarified and the rule about not being able to donate on players aged 13-15 should surely be removed due to the three skill above restriction.
|
|
|
Post by trulskaare on Nov 7, 2019 9:06:48 GMT
Same goes for Baresi at Osasuna.
|
|
|
Post by Dillon (OSA) on Nov 7, 2019 11:39:52 GMT
Think the skill cap on youths was removed last season actually, I took Rose on loan and he was 17 21 at the time. There was an email that went out at the time. You can't scout u16 anymore either so they'll be phased out the game. New rule for donations + caps is: No cap for skills on any youths, you're able to donate 1000abs on any player receiving EOS abs. It's the main reason I shelled out 101m for Rose, he's 18 years old and 25 rated with 3000 donation abs to come over the next 3 seasons along with x15 eos abs. Could easily end up 22 years old 32 rated without much worry at all. I'll be doing the same with Baresi as well Hopefully have Shaw, Baresi and Rose running a season of conceding <10 in the whole season lmao
|
|
|
Post by trulskaare on Nov 7, 2019 12:53:15 GMT
OK thanks. I don't remember the email and couldn't find it when doing a search in my inbox. If this is the case, the information on the forum should have been updated.
|
|
|
Donations
Nov 7, 2019 14:36:24 GMT
via mobile
Post by Malky(Admin) on Nov 7, 2019 14:36:24 GMT
OK thanks. I don't remember the email and couldn't find it when doing a search in my inbox. If this is the case, the information on the forum should have been updated. I'm sure Dillon told you about this not long ago when you asked about it and you commented something like 'oh cool'
|
|
|
Post by trulskaare on Nov 7, 2019 14:53:59 GMT
OK thanks. I don't remember the email and couldn't find it when doing a search in my inbox. If this is the case, the information on the forum should have been updated. I'm sure Dillon told you about this not long ago when you asked about it and you commented something like 'oh cool' I think you're confusing this topic about under 17s not having their skill more than three above their age and the donation on players 21 and below: malkymckay.proboards.com/thread/8084/celtics-season-transfer-listed-playersSo you're confirming that all restrictions are removed and we're back to where we started?
|
|
|
Post by Malky(Admin) on Nov 7, 2019 15:21:59 GMT
I'm sure Dillon told you about this not long ago when you asked about it and you commented something like 'oh cool' I think you're confusing this topic about under 17s not having their skill more than three above their age and the donation on players 21 and below: malkymckay.proboards.com/thread/8084/celtics-season-transfer-listed-playersSo you're confirming that all restrictions are removed and we're back to where we started? You are right it was from the thread above where you commented 'nice' not sure what you mean by 'we're back to where we started' there may still be a couple of players in the 13-15 year age bracket still flouting around but they will soon age under 17 scout missions were removed last season so the youngest is 17-21 3 skill between age and skill was also removed as academies were introduced and managers started to concentrate on development etc emails were sent out to confirm donations on players 21 and under only regardless of skill i apologize if this was not updated on the forum rules section, so much to do and must have slipped through the net
|
|
|
Post by trulskaare on Nov 7, 2019 15:35:23 GMT
Thanks for clarifying. I must admit I did not see those changes in your email. What I mean by "going back to where we started" is that you've removed the 21 skill cap for donations and the three skill above age for 17 year olds. You put those in place to restrict super youths being created initially, admittedly alongside bonus tweaks. It just feels like the changes are made for a temporary time and then it changes after a few seasons, making it difficult to create stability in squad and youth development. Will we start complaining in four or five seasons when we're all sitting with 35-40 rated players in the top division and the gap between the lower divisions is too big again? Not sure these are for the greater good.
|
|
|
Post by Malky(Admin) on Nov 7, 2019 16:00:30 GMT
Thanks for clarifying. I must admit I did not see those changes in your email. What I mean by "going back to where we started" is that you've removed the 21 skill cap for donations and the three skill above age for 17 year olds. You put those in place to restrict super youths being created initially, admittedly alongside bonus tweaks. It just feels like the changes are made for a temporary time and then it changes after a few seasons, making it difficult to create stability in squad and youth development. Will we start complaining in four or five seasons when we're all sitting with 35-40 rated players in the top division and the gap between the lower divisions is too big again? Not sure these are for the greater good. these changes for skill caps to age were made in 2013 which was six years ago so roughly 12 seasons ago take your player K_Mbappe, aged 19 skill 27, he has including this season 17 season until he retires, so that is around 9 real years, i will be 55 K_Mbappe could retire aged 36 skill 45, with Barcelona being the champions, from the very start of EFL and its been in the program which i can send you the max skill is set to 50 we all love EFL but we have to be realistic and ask if it will still be running by 2028??? we have developed over the seasons, some rules are put in place at the time, keepers will have to have there skill cap removed at some point also if outfield players skills get too close we have created an extra option for managers by removing the skill cap to let them concentrate on developing 'stars', not all managers are buying into this including me cause i'd rather spend my money on the present not the future so i say enjoy the game for what we have now, enjoy the challenge, and the many option we now have to shape our clubs into what we want them to be as managers
|
|
|
Post by trulskaare on Nov 7, 2019 17:21:54 GMT
Thanks for clarifying and I understand it's not easy to please everyone.
|
|
|
Post by kaiserbilge on Nov 7, 2019 17:39:23 GMT
I also thought it was this season it all started, and I think Bryn said 'nice' fairly recently, not last season. But at the end of that day it's first in best dressed. A couple of youths that benefitted last season were Mark robinson ( Chelseas to Marseille 45m) and M rose (Sunderalnd to Rangers 20m), doing well!
|
|
|
Post by Malky(Admin) on Nov 7, 2019 17:52:25 GMT
I also thought it was this season it all started, and I think Bryn said 'nice' fairly recently, not last season. But at the end of that day it's first in best dressed. A couple of youths that benefitted last season were Mark robinson ( Chelseas to Marseille 45m) and M rose (Sunderalnd to Rangers 20m), doing well! it was this season, and yes Bryn did say nice fairly recently, not sure the relevance to what you mean
|
|
|
Post by kaiserbilge on Nov 7, 2019 18:06:58 GMT
I'm confused that's all, if it was this season, then how come Rose and robinson started 17 21 last season? Maybe there's a way of putting it in the EFL FA section on the main site?
|
|
|
Post by kaiserbilge on Nov 9, 2019 21:53:31 GMT
So in a nutshell, a few clubs got a 1 season head start.
|
|
|
Donations
Nov 9, 2019 21:59:10 GMT
via mobile
Post by Malky(Admin) on Nov 9, 2019 21:59:10 GMT
So in a nutshell, a few clubs got a 1 season head start. Explain?
|
|