|
Post by pezza @ Marseille on Jul 6, 2023 16:07:01 GMT
We would like to challenge the deal between Barcelona and Roma
The players going to Roma are practically worthless in exchange for Roma's best player
|
|
|
Post by Chris@Bayern Munich on Jul 6, 2023 16:14:45 GMT
I challenge this deal too very one sided
|
|
Pierre
Youth Player
Posts: 236
|
Post by Pierre on Jul 7, 2023 5:23:39 GMT
I also challenge this deal. Not because I think it must be a instant ‘no’, but I think its good when somebody gets a good look at it.
Like Chris said, the deal is to much one sided and David could get much more out of it. But from the other hand, both managers are experienced managers, so …..
|
|
|
Post by andieglen on Jul 7, 2023 19:38:33 GMT
Since I have took over Valencia, I've noticed a short fall in defenders. As they needed a few, just before anyone says anything, they ain't more valuable just under developed.
My reserves are jam packed with youth, those youth are a product of donations, scout missions and having a bit of success, they ain't cheap.
So reality is! I offered my best youth to a seasoned manager who holds value in youth, not a big issue IMO
The same manager who rejected loads of deals involving top end player deals, so the question is, is it a bad deal
|
|
|
Post by Dillon (OSA) on Jul 7, 2023 21:26:35 GMT
Definitely a bad deal, I'm contesting it as well. Although I think we've already had our answer on it.
The way I see the deal is:
De Gear - value 2-3m, 18 21 keepers have very little value in the game right now Puyol - 3m or less, plenty of these players available on auction and he only has .019tk abs. He's essentially a 20 22, without the value of donation to get to 20 23.9 T_S_Silva - 5m, again plenty of these players available and going for similar Benzem - 5m or less, I've tried getting rid of a similar player and they barely budge at that price.
Total ~15m at most. Roma have a level 0 academy, so potentially the deal is only really worth 7.5m-10m based on their growth potential.
Artur - at 30 30, he's prime DF material for a lot of clubs. I sold a 28 28 for 29m, there's a 29 29 on auction for 30.4m as of writing. A 30 30 is worth more than a 28 28 and 29 29, his price is probably around 35-40m, maybe more with academy factor taken into account.
IMO for the deal to be fair Barca should be giving up another 20-30m just on pure balance in the deal.
|
|